A woman who calls herself “Proud Muslimah” posted an imaginary dialogue with a Christian, which she titled, “the logic of Christianity.” It reads:
“Who is God? Jesus
Who is Jesus? the son of God
Who is the father of mankind? Adam
Who is Adam’s father? Jesus (who was ‘born after’ by the way)
Okay, then who created Mary? God
Who is Jesus’s mother? Mary
Does God have a beginning? no
Then what is Christmas? the celebration of Jesus being born
Does god have an end? no
Then did he die on the cross? yes,
Will Jesus be resurrected from the dead? yes
Who will resurrect him? God.”
Let’s take a closer look at this fake dialogue to see if we can spot the fallacies.